In case you missed it, hands-free pumps are all the trend and a welcomed change for multitasking mothers seeking to ditch the every day seated pumping classes. However likelihood is, you stumbled upon this mixed overview since you’re not a lot questioning if a hands-free possibility is of curiosity, however which one is your best option for you. Learn on for an in-depth take a look at the present prime fashions and issues to contemplate before you purchase.

This put up might include affiliate hyperlinks, which signifies that in the event you make a purchase order, we’ll obtain compensation at no extra price to you. We assist and suggest these merchandise as fellow mothers ourselves!

To start with, it’s essential to notice that these two phrases will be simply confused, although they imply very various things with regard to mother’s person expertise.

Wi-fi pumps are cellular fashions that can help you pump with out the necessity for outlet due to a rechargeable or battery operated motor. The caveats are there should be wires connecting the pump components (such because the freemie, freemie liberty or Medela Freestyle Flex), and you should still have to carry the pump as much as your breasts or enlist the assistance of a combo nursing bra/hands-free pumping bra; whereas the on-the-go ingredient is tremendous useful, it could actually nonetheless make pumping in sure conditions—like an workplace assembly or throughout faculty drop-off—a bit tough.

Arms-free wearable pumps additionally supply portability and are battery operated, however every pump acts as its personal wire-free unit with an impartial motor and milk bag assortment system. Which means if you wish to have a double pump, you’ll truly personal two particular person breast pumps to put on straight inside your bra. These fashions give mother tons of freedom and supply discreet expression wherever at anytime with out the majority of a standard pump-and-pumping-bra combo. The method is much less clunky and will be particularly useful in the event you solely must pump on one aspect, or in the event you wish to pump whilst you breastfeed from the alternative aspect and don’t wish to use a silicone assortment cup, such because the haakaa.

Right here’s the breakdown of the principle distinctions between the Elvie and Willow:

Hold scrolling for extra particulars on their variations …

Each double units run for about $500. Nevertheless, you should buy both a single ($279 checklist value) or double pump with the Elvie, however solely have the choice to purchase a double with Willow. The Willow provides financing by means of Affirm, whereas Elvie works with PayPal for month-to-month installments as little as $46 a month. Each settle for FSA/HSA funds and each ship free of charge.

One other factor to notice is in the event you’re within the US, you’re entitled to a free breast pump by means of your insurance coverage. Nevertheless, coverage protection dictates what sorts of free pumps fall inside your community and will restrict your decisions. It is not uncommon for insurance policies to not supply full reimbursement for the Willow or Elvie, however you should still obtain a reduced value on your out-of-pocket expense. Examine with third-party sources like Aeroflow Breastpumps to examine your qualification standing and store for pumps.

You’ll wish to take into consideration how you propose to retailer your breast milk and your storage wants earlier than deciding on the “purchase now” button.

The Elvie comes with reusable 5-ounce bottles that may be saved within the fridge or freezer. It doesn’t permit for disposable luggage, which means in the event you plan to retailer massive portions, you’ll have to purchase separate storage luggage and plan to switch the milk after every session—which could be a trouble.

Alternatively, The Willow permits mother to pump straight into disposable luggage or a reusable container. This spill-proof bag design makes for simpler, extra environment friendly storage with zero transfers and extra mobility for mother (bending over, mendacity down, and so on.), although at Four ounces a bit, you’ll be changing luggage extra typically in the event you select to go that route. For those who’re solely pumping, it might be smart to purchase the reusable milk container to get extra bang on your buck, as a pack of 48 luggage will price you $24, and also you’ll use two (or extra) luggage per session. For instance: For those who pump 5 instances a day and use 10 luggage minimal, you’ll want round 300 per 30 days, which prices upwards of $168 per 30 days—cha-ching!

It’s essential to reiterate that each fashions include small assortment containers and will not be capable of sustain with each mother’s manufacturing wants. For those who pump greater than the bag or bottle holds, every pump will mechanically cease to keep away from overflowing. Each corporations guarantee that it’s fast and simple to pause and change a bag or bottle, however this isn’t at all times real looking and could also be a dealbreaker for some. These fashions could also be finest suited as secondary pumps to a standard double-electric breast pump that serves a higher output. For mothers that overproduce or have excessive provides, the Willow and Elvie most likely wouldn’t work effectively as a main pump.

The one time you’ll want an outlet with a hands-free pump is for charging. On this occasion, each fashions take about two hours to achieve a full cost.

For those who’re quick on time, the Willow boasts a 20-minute cost will get you thru your subsequent pumping session, and full cost ought to final about 5 classes. The Elvie lasts round 2.5 hours on a full cost, however does specify that stage of depth impacts longevity.

You’ll obtain two charging cables with the Elvie (if bought as a double), however might want to purchase an extra charger for the Willow if you wish to cost each on the similar time.

Along with discovering the precise pump, mothers want to make sure they’re utilizing the correctly sized breast defend to guard their nipples and encourage a constructive breastfeeding and pumping expertise. Word that sizes aside from those listed beneath are usually not supported to be used by both pump.

The Elvie comes with 24mm and 28mm shields (typically referred to as flanges), and a pack of 21mm shields will be bought individually. Shields are sized based mostly on the width of the bottom of your nipple. Keep in mind that nipple measurement can change over the course of your breastfeeding journey, so maintain onto extra defend sizes simply in case! For assist with Elvie Pump sizing, click on right here.

Willow provides 21mm (with the reusable container), 24mm and 27mm. They encourage mothers to seek out their finest flange measurement with a ruler app on their cellphone. For extra data and particulars on measuring, take a look at this sizing information useful resource.

As an entire, each fashions are closed methods and supply seven totally different depth ranges of suction, however Willow operates utilizing the primary three ranges within the stimulation section, after which permits for the remaining ranges post-expression. Each pumps have the power to sense your milk letdown and can mechanically change to expression mode when prepared.

Elvie makes an essential level that your highest snug setting is normally your best setting for the next quantity of milk manufacturing, so that they suggest making an attempt out totally different ranges till you discover the precise match. Pressure causes stress, which might have an effect on your milk provide, so attempt to loosen up and ease into it!

Willow and Elvie have apps accessible for iOS and Android gadgets. The apps are downloadable from the app retailer and will be linked to your pump.

Common options embrace the power to energy your pump on or off, modify the depth of suction energy throughout pumping, monitor your output for present classes and see your general manufacturing extra time for every breast.

Each pumps may also join by way of Bluetooth, which has raised questions with regard to security. Willow states that it meets all relevant security requirements for protected Bluetooth use throughout pumping, whereas Elvie explains they use Bluetooth Low Power with decrease emission; extra particulars will be discovered right here.

Each firm web sites supply intensive FAQs and troubleshooting content material that can assist you shortly discover the solutions or options to questions or issues that may pop up.

For those who nonetheless must contact a reside particular person, Elvie buyer care crew will be reached at questions@elvie.com. Willow’s customer support is on the market over the cellphone or by way of textual content throughout enterprise hours at 1-888-WILLOW-Three or by e mail at care@willowpump.com.

Please do not forget that the Willow and Elvie can’t be returned as soon as opened. In case your pump or equipment are broken, you will have a two-year guarantee with Elvie Pump and 90 days on the pump components; the Willow features a one-year guarantee from date of buy in addition to alternative components for 90 days.

Elvie Pump, from $499

Willow Pump, $500